Spectacular Glass Estate Could Become the Most Expensive Sale in Fire Island’s Cherry Grove—Even With a Price Cut

A stunning glass modernist estate, with jaw-dropping views of Fire Island and the surrounding Atlantic Ocean, has once again received a massive price cut.Originally listed in July 2026 for $5,250,000, the four-bedroom Cherry Grove residence known as Crest House dropped to $4,850,000 a few weeks later."Cherry Grove is a uniquely special place, and the market there is equally unique," says listing agent Nikola (Niko) Cejic of Douglas Elliman's Lord Chapin Team. "The highest price ever sold is $2.7 million, so $3 [million] to $3.5 million is the top of the market."Loading...Crest House in Cherry Grove, NYRise MediaLoading...The estate is being offered fully furnished, providing a turnkey opportunity for the next buyer.Rise MediaLoading...The kitchen of the home. It was custom built in 2012 and offers 120 feet of direct ocean frontage.Rise MediaIf it sells anywhere near the asking price of $3,995,000, it would be the most expensive property ever sold in Cherry Grove, Fire Island's iconic LGBTQ+ community."We have had over 350 people view the house," Cejic says. "It got the most attention of any listing but wasn't selling."Located on a rare 120-foot double lot, the 7,130-square-foot est...