Is Naples, Florida a Good Place To Live? 10 Pros and Cons to Consider

Nestled on the picturesque Gulf Coast of Florida, Naples has long been regarded as a captivating destination renowned for its pristine beaches, vibrant cultural scene, and luxurious lifestyle. As you contemplate the idea of moving to Naples, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons of living in this sun-drenched city. From its flourishing economy and abundant recreational opportunities to its high cost of living and occasional natural hazards, there is a lot to consider. In this Redfin article, we will delve into the 10 most significant pros and cons of living in Naples. So whether you’re looking at apartments for rent in Naples, browsing homes for sale, or you’re wondering if Naples is a good place to live – keep reading to learn more.

Interested in moving to Naples? Check out:
Homes for sale in Naples, FL | Apartments for rent in Naples, FL | Houses for rent in Naples, FL

Quick Facts about Naples

1. Pro: Breathtaking beaches

Naples, the gem of Florida’s Paradise Coast, offers a beach lover’s paradise with miles of pristine, soft, white sands lapped by turquoise waters. Not only are these beaches stunning, but they are also well-maintained and offer a serene place to relax, sunbathe, or engage in water sports. Naples’ shoreline delivers a visual feast and the quintessential coastal Florida lifestyle, from the picturesque Barefoot Beach Preserve to Lowdermilk Beach Park.

Deciding between renting or buying your next home? Explore your options.

Compare the costs of renting vs buying and find a lender to secure your mortgage.

Deciding between renting or buying your next home?

Compare the costs of renting vs buying and find a lender to secure your mortgage.

2. Con: High housing costs 

One significant downside of living in Naples, Florida is the high cost of housing. The allure of the city’s stunning natural beauty and upscale amenities comes at a price, and that price often translates into steep housing costs. When it comes to Naples, Florida real estate, you’ll find that housing prices are considerably higher compared to other cities in Florida. The median sales price in Naples reached $715,000 In comparison, the median sale price in Orlando stood at a more affordable $407,000, while in Tampa, it amounted to $497,000.

The demand for housing in this desirable location, coupled with limited available land for development, has resulted in a tight housing market and elevated prices. Additionally, the cost of living, in general, tends to be higher in Naples, which can further strain budgets and impact overall affordability.

3. Pro: Vibrant arts and culture scene

For the culturally inclined, Naples won’t disappoint. The city brims with a rich and lively arts scene that echoes in its many galleries, performance venues, and arts festivals. Institutions such as the Naples Philharmonic and the Baker Museum host a variety of world-class performances and exhibitions. Art shows, craft fairs, and cultural festivals are staples in the local calendar, offering regular opportunities for residents to immerse themselves in a diverse tapestry of artistic expression.

4. Con: Crowds of tourists

Being a popular tourist destination, Naples can get quite crowded, especially during the winter when ‘snowbirds’ from colder states flock to enjoy the balmy Florida weather. The influx of tourists can lead to overcrowded beaches, long wait times at restaurants, and a general increase in the hustle and bustle around the city, potentially hampering the tranquil lifestyle some residents seek.

5. Pro: A unique resort lifestyle

Living in Naples feels like an endless vacation with dozens of unique things to do, courtesy of its resort-like ambiance. From high-end shopping districts and gourmet dining venues to luxury spas, the city rolls out a sophisticated lifestyle that mirrors the world’s most popular resort destinations. The array of well-manicured golf courses, lavish residential communities, and top-notch services create a distinct sense of living in a luxurious retreat, offering residents the perks of a holiday year-round.

6. Con: Danger of hurricanes

Naples’ tropical paradise charm is somewhat tarnished by its vulnerability to hurricanes. Like much of Florida, the city faces an annual threat of these severe storms. This year alone, on average, floods have caused $1,399 in property damage for homeowners. While modern infrastructure and advanced warning systems mitigate the risks, residents must be prepared for potential evacuations, property damage, and the stress associated with hurricane season.

7. Pro: Endless outdoor adventures

Naples is an outdoor enthusiast’s dream, with a smorgasbord of activities. The city’s adjacency to the Everglades presents fantastic kayaking, hiking, bird watching, and wildlife spotting opportunities. Fishing and boating enthusiasts will love the accessibility to the Gulf of Mexico’s bountiful waters. Whether it’s a serene bike ride along the city’s picturesque paths or an exhilarating jet ski adventure, Naples caters to all shades of outdoor passions.

8. Con: Low walkability

Despite its many charms, Naples falls short of walkability. The city has a below-average Walk Score of 35, indicating a strong dependence on cars. This can be a downside for those who prefer a lifestyle where amenities are within walking distance. 

9. Pro: Golf capital of the world

For golf lovers, Naples is nothing short of paradise. Fondly known as the “Golf Capital of the World,” the city offers a stunning array of meticulously designed courses that cater to beginners and experts alike. With over 90 golf courses and glorious golfing weather that lasts almost all year, the city delivers an unmatched golfing experience–a compelling reason to consider Naples your new home.

House hunting made easy

See new home listings on the Redfin app every 5 minutes that match your saved searches.

10. Con: Scorching summer heat

Summers in Naples can be intensely hot and humid. The city’s tropical monsoon climate means that summer temperatures frequently rise into the 90s (Fahrenheit), with high humidity levels adding to the discomfort. Those not used to such weather might find the summer months challenging and need to consider this aspect before moving.

Methodology: The median home sale price and average monthly rental data is from the Redfin Data Center. The Walk Score, Transit Score and Bike Score data is from Walk Score.