Disadvantages of Sellers Paying Closing Costs: 6 Things to Consider

Key takeaways: 

• Sellers sometimes agree to cover closing costs to attract buyers or speed up the sale, but this concession comes at a cost.
• On a $400,000 home, a 3% closing cost concession could reduce your net proceeds by $12,000.
• Raising the sale price to offset these costs may create appraisal or financing challenges, while also lowering the buyer’s financial commitment.
• Before agreeing, weigh alternatives such as repair credits, flexible closing dates, or using a discount brokerage to keep more of your proceeds.

Covering a buyer’s closing costs can be a strategic way to attract buyers and speed up the selling process, but it isn’t always to the seller’s benefit. The disadvantages of sellers paying closing costs include cutting into your final profit, weakening your negotiating position, and potentially making your property seem less competitive if buyers expect similar concessions elsewhere. In some cases, it could even affect how buyers view your home’s value, leading to challenges during appraisal or financing.

Whether you’re selling a home in Newton, MA, Holmdel, NJ or Sammamish, WA this Redfin guide will walk you through the disadvantages of sellers paying closing costs and key factors to weigh before deciding if it’s the right move for your situation.

6 key disadvantages sellers should consider before paying closing costs

Buyer closing costs are the fees and expenses a buyer must cover at the end of a real estate transaction, such as loan origination charges, appraisal fees, title insurance, escrow services, and property taxes. These costs can quickly add up to thousands of dollars, possibly creating a financial strain on buyers.

Some sellers will consider covering a buyer’s closing costs as a strategic move, but it’s important to weigh the financial and negotiation risks. 

1. Reduced net profit

If a seller agrees to pay part of the buyer’s closing costs, it comes out of the seller’s profit. For example, on a $350,000 home, a 3% concession would reduce the seller’s net proceeds by $10,500.

2. Buyer has lower financial commitment

When buyers don’t have to cover closing costs themselves, they may feel less financially committed. This can increase the risk of the buyer backing out or encountering financing issues before closing.

3. Higher overall closing costs

Sometimes, when a seller agrees to cover closing costs, the buyer will increase their offer price to balance it out. While this might seem like it cancels out, it can actually raise the total closing costs (since they’re based on the purchase price) and make the negotiations more complicated.

4. Negotiation weakness and buyer expectations

Once a seller agrees to cover certain costs, buyers may use that as leverage to request additional concessions, such as repairs or other financial incentives. It can set a precedent for further negotiation demands.

5. Appraisal and financing risks

Increasing the sale price to cover closing costs can affect the loan-to-value ratio, possibly creating complications with the buyer’s financing or appraisal. Lenders (FHA, VA, USDA, conventional) also cap how much sellers can contribute, which may limit what you can offer.

6. Tax implications and mortgage impact

While less obvious, paying a buyer’s closing costs can have tax implications and may affect the seller’s mortgage or future financing plans. Consulting a tax professional is recommended to understand potential consequences.

How location and market conditions affect these disadvantages

While considering the disadvantages of sellers paying closing costs, it’s worth keeping in mind that location and market conditions can affect these disadvantages as well. In a seller’s market, where buyers are competing, sellers usually have little reason to offer concessions. But in a buyer’s market, covering closing costs can make a home more attractive and help it sell faster.

>> Read: Is it a Buyer’s or Seller’s Market?

Why sellers consider paying buyers’ closing costs

Sellers sometimes agree to cover part or all of these costs as a strategy to make their home more appealing and move the transaction forward, often for reasons such as:

• Attract more buyers: Paying closing costs can make a property more attractive to buyers, particularly in competitive markets.
• Speed up the sale: Offering this concession may encourage quicker offers and reduce time on the market.
• Help first-time or cash-strapped buyers: Buyers can struggle with down payments, so closing cost assistance can be helpful for home purchases.
• Simplify negotiations: By easing financial pressure on the buyer, sellers can avoid a prolonged closing process.

Alternatives to covering buyer closing costs

If the disadvantages of paying closing costs outweigh the benefits, sellers have other ways to make their home attractive without reducing net proceeds:

• Raise the listing price to offset concessions: By adjusting the asking price slightly higher, sellers can cover buyer incentives without losing as much net profit.
• Offer repair credits instead of cash: Rather than paying closing costs, provide credits for necessary repairs or updates, giving buyers flexibility while limiting out-of-pocket expenses for the seller.
• Split the costs with buyers: Meeting in the middle can reduce the buyer’s burden without requiring the seller to cover everything.
• Provide other incentives: Options like offering a home warranty, allowing a flexible closing date, or leaving behind appliances can make the deal more attractive without directly paying closing costs.

Tips to mitigate the risks if you do pay

If you do decide to cover some or all of a buyer’s closing costs, there are ways to minimize the potential downsides. 

• Cap the dollar amount you’ll contribute: Set a limit on how much you’re willing to pay so the concession doesn’t spiral beyond what you’re comfortable with.
• Make seller concessions transparent in the contract: Spell out the details in writing to avoid misunderstandings and ensure both parties are clear on the terms.
• Work with your agent to price strategically: An experienced real estate agent can help you adjust the listing price to account for concessions while keeping your home competitive.
• Structure the concession as a closing credit, not a blanket cover: Framing the contribution as a credit tied to specific costs gives you more control over how funds are applied.

Weighing the decision

While covering a buyer’s closing costs can attract offers and accelerate a sale, the disadvantages of reduced profits, weaker negotiating power, and possible financing challenges are significant. Before agreeing, calculate your net proceeds with and without concessions, and explore alternatives that preserve your earnings while still appealing to buyers.

FAQs: Disadvantages of seller paying closing costs

1. How much do closing costs typically run for buyers?

Buyer closing costs can vary by state and depend on several factors. In New Jersey, they usually range from 2% to 5% of the home’s purchase price. This includes fees like loan origination, appraisal, title insurance, escrow, and prepaid property taxes or insurance. For example, on a $400,000 home, closing costs might total $8,000 to $20,000.

2. Can sellers deduct closing costs they pay on taxes?

Generally, sellers cannot deduct closing costs they pay on a personal residence as an expense. However, some costs may reduce the taxable gain on the sale of the home. Consulting a tax professional is recommended to understand the specific implications.

3. Are there closing costs if the buyer pays in cash?

Yes, there are still closing costs if the buyer pays in cash, but they’re typically lower. Cash buyers avoid lender fees, but they’ll still pay for things like title insurance, escrow services, transfer taxes, and recording fees.

>> Read: Are There Closing Costs if You Pay Cash for a House?

4. What’s a reasonable concession in today’s market?

A typical seller concession today is often 1% to 3% of the sale price, depending on the region and market conditions. For example, on a $350,000 home, a reasonable concession might range from $3,500 to $10,500, enough to help the buyer with closing costs without significantly impacting the seller’s net proceeds.